We present a comparative analysis of 13 yeasts available for mead (honey wine) fermentation, a source of Saccharomyces cerevisiae diversity that has not yet been analyzed in detail. Using genomic, phenotyping, and analytic methods, we show that currently available mead yeasts belong to various clades of the species, most commonly to the Commercial Wine clade (5 of 13 samples). Mead yeasts in this group displayed genome structure variations and occasional loss of killer activity, despite being closely related. Historic European and traditional African mead isolates with sequenced genomes were found not to be closely related to any contemporary mead yeast product. The 13 yeasts tested here displayed high variability in oenological characteristics and in aroma production. Maximum ethanol tolerance ranged from 15 to 22% v/v, however, the most tolerant strain produced lower ethanol levels and retained high fructose content in experimental meads. The most abundant aroma components produced in meads were ethyl acetate, ethyl caprylate, isoamyl alcohol, and ethyl caprate, with similar aroma profiles in members of the Commercial Wine clade, and pronounced differences among other yeasts. Our results contribute to the knowledge of Saccharomyces yeasts in various fermentation environments, adding mead to the list of alcoholic beverages with a known diversity of starter cultures. Our results may aid strain selection for honey wine fermentations and inspire strain improvement.