The surface of gram-positive bacteria is a highly regulated environment with specific attachment of proteins required for viability. Sortase enzymes are cysteine transpeptidases that recognize and ligate substrates to the peptidoglycan layer in these microorganisms, which can be highly pathogenic (e.g., Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus pyogenes, etc.). As such, sortases represent a potentially novel target for antibiotic development. In addition, the catalytic activity of sortase enzymes is utilized in sortase mediated ligation (SML) engineering approaches for a variety of uses. In SML experiments, engineered variants of Staphylococcus aureus sortase A (saSrtA) are the most widely used enzymes. One of the mutated amino acids in the previously engineered pentamutant (or saSrtA5M) enzyme is P94. Structural analyses of experimental saSrtA structures revealed that P94 interacts directly with Y187 when saSrtA is in its inactive conformation. While saSrtA5M, developed via directed evolution, contains a P94R mutation, we wanted to interrogate this position further and ask if other single P94 mutations may reveal a greater effect on activity and/or substrate specificity. We created 18 P94X mutations (excluding P94C), and tested relative activity using a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) assay for 4 substrate sequences: LPATG, LPETG, LPKTG, and LPSTG. We identified several P94 variants that outperformed the single mutant P94R for all peptides tested, including P94A, P94D, P94E, P94G, P94H, P94N, P94Q, P94S, and P94T. We further observed that the reactivity of substrates with variations in the central position of the pentapeptide recognition motif (LPXTG) can be sensitive to the identity of the P94X residue. We tested P94A and P94D saSrtA5M variants and found that